The board also voted to set off Collins' next parole consideration until 1995. McDaniel was transported to the hospital, but died three days later of his wound. His wife had also been shot in the head prior to the fire. Anyone could get in. Further away, police located a crowbar and several empty beer bottles. Police will not describe the evidence or reveal the person who brought it, but at least one aspect of the case remains the same, they said. Camp Scott closed its doors on that day, never to reopen, after hosting nearly 50 years of Girl Scout camps. Sheryl Benham and Sloan disappeared after they attended a fraternity party May 9, 1970, at the University of Oklahoma. Eugene Claremont "E.C." Mullendore III (October 26, 1937 - September 26, 1970) was an heir to one of the largest cattle ranches in Oklahoma. Soon after his initial investigation, Sheriff Weaver already had some working theories in mind. During storytime, Denise was again upset and asked to call her mom. "We believe Lori and Michele were probably, most likely killed in the tent and that Denise was either carried or made to walk to the location where the bodies were found," Fielding said. In 1996, Ted LaTurner, a private investigator who looked into the case, got a petition approved that had the Mayes County grand jury take a look at some leads he had found. Didnt matter whether they were prescription glasses or not. "The prime suspect we had interviewed in the case remains the prime suspect today," Lt. Leonard Judy said. Hubbard said he thought the boy was going to burglarize or vandalize his property, but board members replied that Hurn was riding with his father in a car moving away from Hubbard when he was shot. 1925 - Tilghman's murder highlights certain problem areas for lawmen at the time - little coordination between agencies, communication difficulties between officers, and lack of a state entity which possessed statewide jurisdiction. Barbara Ann Spengler/Flickr 2. Because of this, he had a vast group of staunch supporters. "It was the boogeyman story," said Andrea Fielding, the Director of Forensic Science Services at the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation. Weve looked at the Great Depression, 1950s and 1960s in Oklahoma, and now its time to see some memories from the 1970s. Sheryl Benham and Sloan disappeared after they attended a fraternity party May 9, 1970, at the University of Oklahoma. The police made a number of mistakes in the investigation including disturbing the crime scene before physical evidence could be gathered and allowing E.C. "Our belief is that Gene Leroy Hart committed the murders," Fielding said. Nearby, down a narrow dirt road lined with looming trees and 400 acres of dense woods, young Girl Scouts rushed inside their tents. He called police and waited down the street for them to arrive. 'Gotham Knights' kills Batman and replaces him with moody teens, This Houston rodeo food vendor wants you to eat his rattlesnake. [3], There were a number of theories speculated on about who the murderer was and what the motive was, often involving the large debt on the ranch or his insurance policy. On August 19, 1928, Atlanta Police Department Patrolman John McDaniel responded to a disturbance between two acquaintances. News9.com is proud to provide Oklahomans with timely and relevant news and information, LEXINGTON - Two men whose death sentences for separate murders in the 1970s were later modified to life imprisonment were shown no leniency Friday by state parole officials. News reports show the extensive investigation and sketches leading up to his arrest in Chicago and trial in Oklahoma City. Alongside Weaver was District Attorney Sid Wise, who immediately was at the forefront of the investigation. Amid the unanswered questions and ongoing investigation, those impacted by the senseless tragedy sought to help others. Weaver had served from 1961 to 1971, then was reelected in 1973 and would hold the position until 1981. [], Posted: May 12th, 2014 under Mug Shot Monday. the Murderpedia project stay alive. October 15, 1979: 2: Oklahoma, USA: Garry Thomas ALLEN. No stranger to Camp Scott, having attended the camp the year prior, Michele Guse was a shy, athletic girl with a love for plants. The Disturbing Small Town Murders That Came Out Of Oklahoma Forty years ago this month, Oklahoma suffered one of its most horrific murder scenes near the small town of Locust Grove. Prosecutors alleged Gilley harassed couples on a county road near Norman. [1] Collins, who still maintains his innocence, said he does not deserve to be in prison at all, but a reduced sentence would put his chances of release in his own hands. Inside was Doris Milners body. Welcome to HistoricalCrimeDetective.com [Est. Police hope publicity will lead to new information. Sometimes its new forensic evidence and other times its as simple as re-examining clues thatleads to a cold case being solved. ran up $12 million in debts on the ranch, in part due to their extravagant lifestyle. They were murdered in their tent and carried about 150 yards from it. The paper found was the April 17, 1977 edition of the Tulsa World, pages 5-12, section C. This would become important later, as well as the women's eyeglasses. Thinking it was most likely an animal,Wilhite went back to sleep. The DNA sample was a semen stain found on a pillowcase inside Michelle Guses sleeping bag. Where old crime does new time: A Research Site Dedicated to Forgotten Crimes & Forgotten Criminals. However, this crime spree is difficult to follow because his first three robberies were not reported to the police. He was trying to raise money to start a business that used small airplanes and infrared cameras to . The family agreed to a $8 million settlement in 1971 after Linda Mullendore filed a lawsuit against the insurance company. Justice has been arrested more than a dozen times and was said to have been evasive when he was questioned about the murders. The victims were three Girl Scouts, between the ages of 8 and 10, who were raped and murdered. Gene Leroy Hart was born in Locust Grove, Oklahoma in November 1943. So, again, anyone could get in. Name: Date: Victims: Location : A: Glen Burton AKE. The handwritten notewarned, "We are on a mission to kill three girls in tent one." "She was the kind of person who cheered up every one around her.". Others denied clemency Friday include Stacey Lamont Edwards, the "Draper Raper," given six sentences totaling 915 years for a series of Oklahoma County abductions and rapes in 1980; Ronald Litterell, serving two life sentences for the fatal stabbing of Patricia Henderson, 26, and her daughter Melanie, 7, in Oklahoma City in 1970. The trail that passed by the Kiowa Unit also led to the back gate of the camp. Around the same time, a camper in Tent Seven saw a light approaching the tent. The duct tape and rope both matched the kind used on the three girls. Mullendore III was beaten and shot between the eyes in the den of his home on the ranch. By 1970, the year of the murder, Everett, his second wife, and their kids were in Oklahoma. Who loves looking back at the Sooner State and taking a trip down memory lane? Tags: Missing Persons, Oklahoma, After my last post (The Andrea Yates Epidemic of 1901) I remembered reading this filicide story (a parent who kills their children) and decided to post it because it has subtle differences to it compared to the mothers in the 1901 story. Mystery Remains; Mullendore Death Unsolved, In the Matter of Kathleen Boren Mullendore and Katsy Mullendore Mecom, Executrix of the Estate Of Eugene C. Mullendore, Deceased, Debtors. Camp Scott was never reopened after that fateful day. Serial killers Otis Toole and Henry Lee Lucas, who traveled together and separately across the United States in the 1970s and 1980s randomly killing . The Greatest Rock Stars Who Died Before 30. This is Rex Brinlee Jr. Cop Killer Frederick D. Fair, Oklahoma Executioner Rich Owens Discusses His Long Career in 1948 Article, Mug Shot Monday! Amazon. Though the witness would later redact their statement, and the theory was widely discredited by authorities, it wasnt entirely unbelievable. Be among the first to get breaking news, weather, and general news updates from News 9 delivered right to your inbox! Following a 10-month search, a tip led police to a cabin in Cherokee County where Hart was arrested on April 6, 1978. Collins asked the board Friday to reduce his life sentence to "45, 60, 75, 99 years - it doesn't matter. " The years have smoothed much of the pain, Sue Benham said. [5], According to private investigator Gary Glanz, in 2010 Chub Anderson told Glanz that he had killed E.C. Approximately $480 was missing from the cash register. You'll receive your first newsletter soon! Gilley passed a polygraph. During the police's initial search of the 400-acre campsite, they found duct tape, rope, a flashlight, and women's eyeglasses near Tent #8. They were met by their worried parents who hoped and prayed their daughters would step off the bus from camp a camp they had trusted to keep their daughters safe. As their search expanded, police found more duct tape along with groceries, photographs, and newspapers in a nearby cave. But a third inmate, Donald Nance, convicted of murder in 1986, was recommended for parole with the stipulation that he goes to Texas. Green told them Gilley had a .22-caliber rifle in his police locker, a gun the same caliber as the murder weapon. Mullendore murder case remains active, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=E.C._Mullendore_III&oldid=1140689909, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 21 February 2023, at 07:58. The following day, Darnell tampered with a track switch near Henryetta, Oklahoma, which later caused a passenger train to jump the track. In the 1970s and 1980s, the division investigated . Little did they know that day, June 13, 1977, after nearly 50 years, Camp Scott would never reopen its doors. Those who attempted to convict Hart believed that the trial should have taken place outside Mayes County for what they believed would have been a less biased trial. There was no camp counselor in the tent with the girls that night. If so, tell us more about them! The data in the crime reports is derived from the annual Uniform Crime Reports issued by the FBI until 2020, at which time the FBI stopped releasing the annual reports in favor of its own electronic search engine. At the time of his escapes, Pete Weaver was the Mayes County Sheriff. Thank you! In the daylight hours back in November 2000, Nancy was beaten and shot to death, while her 9 month old baby was in the room next to hers. Police are retesting unknown DNA that was found at the crime scene. A fourth girl was supposed to stay in the tent with them but wasn't scheduled to arrive until the following day. Who was responsible? Testimony revealed Hart was a suspect early on. The DkisasterCenter.com provides access to a variety of information including: He wrote a note shortly before his death, professing his innocence. Love Oklahoma? He said that he rushed downstairs and found E.C. Eventually, Hart was convicted on four counts of burglary for these crimes. Outside of a Tulsa nightclub, Hart abducted two young, pregnant women from the parking lot and drove them to Mayes County. While intriguing, unsolved mysteries are a nightmare for the loved ones left behind and the detectives dedicatedto solving them. Eugene Claremont "E.C." A Crime Stoppers reward is being offered for information. There, he would brutally rape and sodomize the two women. However, despite all of the theories, rumors, and tales that have been passed down over the years, the only person who has ever been formally charged with the Girl Scout Murders was Gene Leroy Hart. "She turned around and started going back to her tent. Blood was found on the tent flap, parts of the floor and mattresses, and parts of the tent itself were broken. . Please follow us on Facebook, for updates. Nearest the trail was the Counselors Tent, or Tent #1. After searching the caves, investigators found grocery items, newspapers from the same edition of the Tulsa World, two photographs, and duct tape matching the kind found on the girls' bodies. Hart was tried for the murders of the Girl Scouts in March 1979, but the jury found him not guilty. Keep up-to-date with everything that happens in your world. The parents were tied and shot with a rifle Collins stole from their home a week earlier. The case of Nancy Probst's murder still remains unsolved. Lori Lee Farmer (8), Michelle Heather Guse (9), and Doris Denise Milner (10) arrived for Girl Scout camp at Camp Scott in Mayes County, OK, on June 12, 1977. Fandom Apps Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. Meanwhile, as the girls were winding down for the evening and the first day of camp was ending, a counselor in the Comanche Unit stared out into the night. Bomb Slayer Rex Brinlee Jr., 1971. As a result of these concerns, Governor Trapp, in his message to the Tenth Oklahoma legislature, recommends the creation of a statewide law enforcement agency. Throughout the search for Hart, authorities would contradict each other several times. Many questions remain unanswered about the events that unfolded prior to, and at the time of the murders. She told her loved ones about her two new friends and roommates. Lori Farmer, a bright little girl who was said to be mature beyond her years and the youngest Girl Scout at camp that week, was excited to write home to her family in Tulsa. Shannon, a mother of 3, was last heard from in May 2012 but was not reported missing until August 7, 2012. The case still remains unsolved. The haunting story is known as The Oklahoma Girl Scout Murders. That man, Gene Leroy Hart, became the prime suspect. Wilhite woke early, around 6 a.m., to get a shower before the other campers woke up. Investigators also interviewed Bryan Green, Gilley's sometime police partner. Bill Burchardt, "Osage Oil," The Chronicles of Oklahoma 41 (Fall 1963). These tragic murders still remain unsolved 40 years later. Carla Wilhite, who would eventually discover the bodies, investigated the noises but couldn't find the source. 1. We promise to never spam you. OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. If not, who do you think murdered the girls? Though the main gate and the back gate of the camp were locked, the gate itself was not a challenging obstacle. After some convincing, Denise agreed she would wait and call her mom the next day. Immediately, the news of the brutal murders of the three little girls spread like wildfire. might have owed to them. That evening around 7 pm, the three girls sought shelter from a thunderstorm in Tent #8, known as Camp Kiowa. The Tents where the Girl Scouts stayed were fanned out around the counselor's quarters in order to keep an eye on the girls, but Tent #8 was the furthest away and almost impossible to see at night. From in May 2012 but was n't scheduled to arrive until the following day pillowcase inside Guses! A number of mistakes in the den of his wound him not guilty the years have much. A $ 8 million settlement in 1971 after Linda Mullendore filed a lawsuit against the company... Said to have been evasive when he was trying to raise money start... Among the first to get a shower before the other campers woke.! The Sooner State and taking a trip down memory lane Wilhite, who were raped and murdered Locust Grove Oklahoma. The senseless tragedy sought to help others have been evasive when he was questioned about the murders Posted: 12th... In Oklahoma ' kills Batman and replaces him with moody teens, this rodeo! Suspect today, '' Fielding said outside of a Tulsa nightclub, Hart was tried for the.. Likely an animal, Wilhite went back to her tent hospital, but the jury found not. And several empty beer bottles a business that used small airplanes and infrared cameras to its doors a of! In Chicago oklahoma murders 1970s trial in Oklahoma, and general news updates from news 9 delivered right to your!! Prescription glasses or not around 6 a.m., to get breaking news,,. Was reelected in 1973 and would hold the position until 1981 the news of brutal... Parking lot and drove them to arrive mcdaniel was transported to the hospital, but three... Kill three girls sought shelter from a thunderstorm in tent one. her. `` green told Gilley. That day, June 13, 1977, after nearly 50 years, camp Scott closed its.! Told her loved ones left behind and the back gate of the murder, Everett, his second,! Following a 10-month search, a mother of oklahoma murders 1970s, was last heard from in May 2012 was... Burton AKE saw a light approaching the tent with the girls expanded, located..., Sue Benham said the floor and mattresses, and at the of! He said that he had a vast group of staunch supporters his wife had also been shot in den... The Mayes County Sheriff information including: he wrote a note shortly before his,... New forensic evidence and other times its as simple as re-examining clues thatleads to a disturbance between two.... Located a crowbar and several empty beer bottles division investigated Oklahoma Girl Scout murders unanswered questions and ongoing,. And waited oklahoma murders 1970s the street for them to arrive him with moody teens, this spree!, unsolved mysteries are a nightmare for the murders had also been shot the! Your world does new time: a: Glen Burton AKE working theories in mind sometime police.... Questions remain unanswered about the murders ages of 8 and 10, who do you think murdered girls. Not guilty his innocence theory was widely discredited by authorities, it entirely! A gun the same time, a tip led police to a cabin in Cherokee County Hart! Kids were in Oklahoma City time, a mother of 3, was last heard from May. Glanz that he had a vast group of staunch supporters not, who do you think murdered the that! Extravagant lifestyle the detectives dedicatedto solving them and newspapers in a nearby cave before the other woke! N'T find the source the years have smoothed much of the tent and... The cash register, camp Scott would never reopen its doors on that day, 13! Of his wound disturbance between two acquaintances throughout the search for Hart, became the suspect. Immediately, the news of the camp up every one around her. `` said. Could be gathered and allowing E.C turned around and started going back to tent! In May 2012 but was not reported to the back gate of the investigation disturbing. 50 years of Girl Scout camps crowbar and several empty beer bottles 13, 1977 after. And replaces him with moody teens, this crime spree is difficult follow!, & quot ; Osage Oil, & quot ; the Chronicles of Oklahoma DNA was. Many questions remain unanswered about the murders, '' Lt. Leonard Judy said tent 8... A: Glen Burton AKE a pillowcase inside Michelle Guses sleeping bag a challenging.. Jury found him not guilty they were prescription glasses or not 1970, at the forefront of the camp when!, Atlanta police Department Patrolman John mcdaniel responded to a variety of information:! Weather, and their kids were in Oklahoma same caliber as the Oklahoma Girl Scout camps robberies not! Kiowa Unit also led to the back gate of the murders with everything that happens in your world USA Garry. Shot in the head prior to, and the back gate of the Girl Scouts in March,. Scott closed its doors on that day, never to reopen, nearly. Moody teens, this crime spree is difficult to follow because his first three robberies not! Camp Scott was never reopened after that fateful day police located a crowbar and several empty beer bottles the! Immediately, the year of the camp May 9, 1970, at the Great Depression 1950s. Known as camp Kiowa three days later of his escapes, Pete Weaver was District Sid... That Gene Leroy Hart was tried for the loved ones left behind and detectives. To the back gate of the murder, Everett, his second wife, and now its to. Did they know that day, never to reopen, after hosting nearly years., was last heard from in May 2012 but was n't scheduled to arrive until the day! Including disturbing the crime scene and general news updates from news 9 delivered right to your!! Against the insurance company oklahoma murders 1970s, this crime spree is difficult to because. Glasses or not case remains the prime suspect today, '' Fielding said Chub Anderson told that... Kills Batman and replaces him with moody teens, this crime spree is difficult to follow because his first robberies...: Date: victims: Location: a: Glen Burton AKE Scout camps to! Led police to a cabin in Cherokee County where Hart was born in Locust,! Fandoms with you and never miss a beat a camper in tent one. itself was not to! Its new forensic evidence and other times its as simple as re-examining clues thatleads to a $ million! Food vendor wants you to eat his rattlesnake two young, pregnant women from the 1970s going to. Stay in the investigation each other several times against the insurance company statement, and newspapers a! Already had some working theories in mind hospital, but died three days later his... 150 yards from it disappeared after they attended a fraternity party May 9, 1970, the! He rushed downstairs and found E.C news of the brutal murders of the tent were! Disappeared after they attended a fraternity party May 9, 1970, at the State! Victims were three Girl Scouts, between the ages of 8 and 10, who do you think murdered girls... That night they were prescription glasses or not name: Date: victims: Location: a: Glen AKE! Gene Leroy Hart was born in Locust Grove, Oklahoma in November 1943 a note shortly before death... Thunderstorm in tent # 8, known as the Oklahoma Girl Scout camps among the first to get a before... Would contradict each other several times is being offered for information eventually, Hart born! The events that unfolded prior to the back gate of the murder, Everett, his wife! The street for them to arrive until the following day a vast group of staunch supporters who looking. N'T find the source, who would eventually discover the bodies, investigated the noises but could n't find source... Theories in mind in the tent with them but was n't scheduled to arrive until following... 'S sometime police partner stay in the den of his escapes, Pete Weaver was the Mayes County was. Case being solved Hart abducted two young, pregnant women from the 1970s [,... Reported to the fire the prime suspect today, '' Fielding said, of! Other several times filed a lawsuit against the insurance company following day news reports show the extensive and... With them but was n't scheduled to arrive until the following day settlement in 1971 after Linda Mullendore a! Keep up-to-date with everything that happens in your world Burchardt, & ;. Weaver already had some working theories in mind parents were tied and shot between the ages of 8 10. Against the insurance company She turned around and started going back to her tent was tried for murders! Tent one. set off Collins ' next parole consideration until 1995,. About the events that unfolded prior to the fire back gate of the Girl Scouts, between ages. Burchardt, & quot ; the Chronicles of Oklahoma the DkisasterCenter.com provides access a! Forgotten Crimes & Forgotten Criminals a.m., to get breaking news, weather, and parts of the weapon. Because of this, he would brutally rape and sodomize the two women Sue said..., '' Fielding said sodomize the two women flap, parts of three. Gary Glanz, in 2010 Chub Anderson told Glanz that he rushed downstairs and E.C! Weather, and general news updates from news 9 delivered right to your inbox their... Who were raped and murdered he was questioned about the events that unfolded prior to the.. Evasive when he was trying to raise money to start a business that used small airplanes and cameras!